Greetings,
The issue : 2473: Minstrel Unable to Charm "Giants" was closed today due to not enough data.
The issue is : Minstrel should be able to charm "Giants"
Dartmoor Giants / Glacier Giant etc ...
But it also extend to Demons...
(Charmable by minstrel since 1.51, EVEN IF no "Demon" in the charmable list of the speel)...
Naburite Drinker
Realm: All
Type: Demon
Level: 41 - Name: Alluring Melodies. Ability: Charms Humanoids, Animals, Insects and Magical Creatures
As you can see, no Demon or Giant in the description.
It was still possible to charm them tho.
Maybe Demons & Giants were related to Magical Creatures ?
See issue 2473 to get the steps need to see the bug.
Giants & Demons should be charmable by minstrel & mentalist.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://camelotherald.wikia.com/wiki/Patch_Notes:_Version_1.89
Nerf from 1.89
New Frontier Note : Glacier Giant is now resistant to charm spells.
It was charmable before 1.89 then right ? Lot of people remember it.
Remember this : It's a level 75 mob, so ... we are not talking about Sorc Charm here.
We can see this tho :
Glacier Giant
Realm: Midgard
Type:!!!!!! Giant !!!!!!
Even if no Giant mentioned in the charmable list, they were ...
------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://decuscognatio.proboards.com/thread/137
Last post talking about good pet to do xp (It's a MINSTREL forum, with minstrel ressources & formula, it's not a Sorcerer guide ...) :
!!!! naburite drinker do lifedrain and yes they are charmable since 1.52 !!!!
!!!! granite stonelords cast stun !!!!
Even if no Demon mentioned in the charmable list, they were since 1.52.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://camelot.allakhazam.com/db/skills.html?cskill=22
"I've heard more then one report of minstrels soloing Ravenclan Giants by charming one other"
------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.ign.com/boards/threads/huge-pet.250221952/
"I was looking at the new camelot website,
http://www.camelotcentral.net/
and I saw a rather insane screenshot of a person whose pet is an immense "Forest Giant" that is many times larger than a keep.
Uhh...is this for real?"
"Yeah it's real. It's an alb mob that a Sorc/Mins has charmed.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I could find more obviously, but i'll stay with those solid evidence only for now (2 patchnotes 2 forum posts).
We could consider doing a stupid 30 or 40 links list.
However is it really needed to see the evidence ?
|
Issue was invalid:
Closed by reporter |
| 1 player says this report is valid, 0 disagree |