Server decaying

Talk about your RvR experience here
joshisanonymous
Myrmidon
 
Posts: 160
Joined: Feb 10, 2012 09:03

Postby joshisanonymous » May 02, 2017 01:06

Budikah wrote:With what I've seen of Midgards numbers - it's going to take a coordinated effort between Hib/Alb to take and hold anything. I logged on the other day and found a literal sea of Mids - 5/6FG's + rolling around whereas Alb/Hib had nothing but a few 8mans out. Midgard's RvR population at certain times just blows the other realms out of the water that they'll seemingly always be able to easily take whatever they want back during Euro primetime without much of any resistance.

During NA times I feel this evens out, but during Euro times it seems like Midgard just blows the other two realms out of the water. We could take everything during NA times and I feel that once we all go to bed, it's just going to be a free for all without much of a defense to stop the Euro Mid zerg from taking it all back, pretty much uncontested.


It doesn't seem like a big issue to me if relics swap hands back and forth like that. Wouldn't that be a sign of healthy competition? I actually thought Mid should've taken the 6th relic. The reason we didn't was because we wouldn't have relic guards then and would likely lose them all real quick, which to me is perfectly fine because the back and forth means that people are RvRing on a large scale.

Anyway, to everyone else, I get that Albs and Hibs feel outnumbered during EU hours and that the people posting here are dead set on developer intervention or bust. I'm attempting to be productive about this, though, which is only met with hostility. There's no magical reason why Mid is doing well in RvR, but if y'all want to insist that it's impossible and continue with a very drawn out /quit, so be it, but I hope there are people in your realms who aren't looking to give up just yet.
*Current Lives*
Might pop in here on my BD sometimes.
(Atlas) Baudith/RM
*Past Lives*
(MLF) Levlin/Rang > (Bors) Kleib/RM > (Kay) Traep/Minst > (Lancelot Cluster) Chasis/Sav > (Ywain) Finnegin/Ment > (Uthgard) Mordigg/BD > (Phoenix) Kroll/SM > (BL2) Baud/Warlock

Pompernick
Warder
 
Posts: 51
Joined: May 27, 2016 01:42

Postby Pompernick » May 02, 2017 01:18

Not many people are down to log on and RvR at a -30% power deficit while also being outnumbered. No one wants to take keeps because it's boring af and doesn't offer any rps.

No one can be online 24/7 to defend so the dominant realm will have the relics fairly easy.

Nerf the relics to 5% per enemy relic held. Might help the situation.

For real though, make keeps worth RPS+defend rps.

User avatar
Tree
Eagle Knight
 
Posts: 561
Joined: Jan 09, 2017 10:30

Postby Tree » May 02, 2017 04:16

As a Hib, who participated in maybe half of all relic raids and defenses, I dont feel we are entirely helpless. However it is true, that there is nothing much we can do if a certain trashhold is reached. If the Mid Zerg is huge enough, that they can tear down all three relic doors within a few short minutes, no defense effort makes any sense. Usually thanks to Discord most of Hib knows about a relic attack taking places within the first few minutes, bg springs up almost immediately and people suicide/port to Ligen or Cain. From what I experience the swiftness and level of organization is great. And most Hib players are very enthusiastic about defending their relics.
But even though we do everything humanly possible, often times the relic keep has fallen before we can even reach it. And at that point its game over. I remember the one time we Hibs tried to intercept our relic in Mid FZ and had quite a huge force. Mids knew that and moved the relic around in HZ for 1 hour and got more people to log in and join their Zerg. After this hour they just steamrolled us, because there was no way for us Hibs to get more people online and into the raid. The numbers just dont support it. So even though we did everything right, the game mechanics in that particular situation didn't really give us a chance.

What probably needs to change is either a limit on number of rams per door, overall stronger doors at relics and a shorter return timer for relics, so that you actually need to move fast, when you remove a relic from a shrine, and can't idle in HZ forever.
Tree - Animist Lvl 50 (RR 3L0, Legendary Tailor)
Aeomelia - Enchanter Lvl 50
Guild: SCHWERT & ROSE (provisional guild leader)

[HIB] Crafting Mat Wholesale
Diamond, Wyvernskin, Nightshade, Eldritch etc. huge quantities below vendor price - pm me!

Sendnudez
Myrmidon
 
Posts: 89
Joined: Apr 12, 2017 20:05

Postby Sendnudez » May 02, 2017 06:34

^ lmao sheeeiiit
Enchanter

User avatar
Isavyr
Gryphon Knight
 
Posts: 277
Joined: Dec 29, 2010 02:49

Postby Isavyr » May 02, 2017 07:12

Tree, I appreciate your enthusiasm and ideas. But there is a problem with them. They affect balance, and they aren't 1.65. Now, they may be great ideas, but they are an contradiction with two of the sacred pillars of Uthgard.

There may be a day in the near-future when only Blue plays Uthgard, but by god, it will be 1.65.

Ish.

Andreas
Warder
 
Posts: 43
Joined: Mar 16, 2017 10:04

Postby Andreas » May 02, 2017 10:27

Yesterday 1.750 players online. 450 of these were hibs rest (1.300) splitted in mids and albs. Albs have around the same numbers than hib maybe a little bit more. You see the admins are right. They have only 40% more players online maybe we shoul vote for a permanent SH exp bonus that even more players switch to mid and become faster 50 that they can outnumber us 2:1
And yes i play with some hibs they think about it to transfer to mid because it more and more the only realm where pugs make fun.

And yes on live the players stayed in there realms because they had hope that the next patch will change something but with the decison not to change anything in the future less and less players will play hib and stop playing or transfer to mid.

Skallman
Myrmidon
 
Posts: 143
Joined: Dec 15, 2016 10:41

Postby Skallman » May 02, 2017 17:11

Funny thing atm.

Watching Tharid's stream on Twitch now a bit.
He's standing on emain pad in Hibernia. And its 17CET atm. 3 fg mids ported to emain couple mins ago, bufed and ran out.. like wtf? 3fg? Some of them high rr to.

Thats the amount hib got on weekends at evnings, not a ordinary weekday at 17CET.. AT Drum Ligen atm, 1 afk bard, 1 afk vw, couple casters ;P YAY!

Ruckuz1983
Myrmidon
 
Posts: 62
Joined: Mar 13, 2017 23:54

Postby Ruckuz1983 » May 03, 2017 18:06

Skallman wrote:Funny thing atm.

Watching Tharid's stream on Twitch now a bit.
He's standing on emain pad in Hibernia. And its 17CET atm. 3 fg mids ported to emain couple mins ago, bufed and ran out.. like wtf? 3fg? Some of them high rr to.

Thats the amount hib got on weekends at evnings, not a ordinary weekday at 17CET.. AT Drum Ligen atm, 1 afk bard, 1 afk vw, couple casters ;P YAY!



Hibs always complaining maybe that's why people don't enjoy it there...I deleted a 50 bard just saying.
Infection 50 Shaman
Alliant 50 Runemaster

Evinac
Gryphon Knight
 
Posts: 262
Joined: Dec 14, 2016 04:19

Postby Evinac » May 03, 2017 18:42

Ruckuz1983 wrote:
Skallman wrote:Funny thing atm.

Watching Tharid's stream on Twitch now a bit.
He's standing on emain pad in Hibernia. And its 17CET atm. 3 fg mids ported to emain couple mins ago, bufed and ran out.. like wtf? 3fg? Some of them high rr to.

Thats the amount hib got on weekends at evnings, not a ordinary weekday at 17CET.. AT Drum Ligen atm, 1 afk bard, 1 afk vw, couple casters ;P YAY!



Hibs always complaining maybe that's why people don't enjoy it there...I deleted a 50 bard just saying.


How's the bandwagon?
Evinak - Eldritch
Evinac - Hero
<Blazed>

Jaerun
Warder
 
Posts: 34
Joined: Apr 19, 2017 22:46

Postby Jaerun » May 03, 2017 20:02

joshisanonymous wrote:
Budikah wrote:During NA times I feel this evens out, but during Euro times it seems like Midgard just blows the other two realms out of the water. We could take everything during NA times and I feel that once we all go to bed, it's just going to be a free for all without much of a defense to stop the Euro Mid zerg from taking it all back, pretty much uncontested.


It doesn't seem like a big issue to me if relics swap hands back and forth like that. Wouldn't that be a sign of healthy competition? I actually thought Mid should've taken the 6th relic. The reason we didn't was because we wouldn't have relic guards then and would likely lose them all real quick, which to me is perfectly fine because the back and forth means that people are RvRing on a large scale.


If the relics swap back and forth, then yes that would be a sign of healthy competition. But what Joshisanonymous is suggesting, is not "swapping" back and forth. It is that it takes a large amount of effort for an underdog realm, or even a realm that is evenly matched with its opponent, to organize and carry out a successful relic raid. It is tremendously demoralizing to know that all of that effort will be wiped out overnight, when the other realm logs in while you are asleep and undoes what you spent days planning and hours carrying out.

On Igraine mids were usually the underdog realm, and Hibs had a large russian population. Mid Igraine ran a phenomenal stealthy relic raid during prime time NA -- within five minutes of first keep spam reported, all 7 keeps dropped. Within 20 minutes of first keep spam, both mid relics were freed and recovered. That same night, mid lost one or both of its relics, i forget, to hibs' russian guild. It was a long time before mids recovered and tried again.

A momentary, <24 hr, interruption in Mid's dominance is not "swapping" and is not a sign of healthy competition.

Edit: fixed quote
Last edited by Jaerun on May 03, 2017 23:45, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
MotaroReloaded
Eagle Knight
 
Posts: 707
Joined: Aug 31, 2010 00:00
Location: London

Postby MotaroReloaded » May 03, 2017 23:41

Satiah wrote:
Isavyr wrote:
Vlalkor wrote:I can tell you that hibs themselves killed their own realm. I cant tell you how many days I tried to get grps together or join other grps as a druid and came up empty because a group would literally wait 40 minutes for their guildie to log in instead.


One group doing this doesn't effectively kill the realm.

I said it before, and I'll say it again: slow experience kills RvR. It is necessary to have second characters to create group compositions, and groups stagnate when they're left unable to fill spots.

And they're unable to fill spots because slow XP guarantees there are fewer people with backup chars.


I'm in an active guild, which isn't active in RvR at all even though we try every once in a whiled. We can have 15 players online all doing there own thing. Some of the lvl 50 druids and BM's will try to go out and RvR, but even they are having a hard time finding spots. Most of them will idle for an hour and just log and that's just it. No groups, no point to go out on small groups, etc. It's 8vs8 or bust.

I'm pretty sure that of the 2000 people online max currently, most of them are lvl'ing alts or are crafting (for a better day). Even if we hade insta50 at this point it wouldnt make a difference. There's no point to go out and RvR, unless you want to get rolled on with your pug. The casuals arent having fun RvR'ing. period.

So what we're left with is a hardcore PvE server with a 8vs8 RvR community. All the solo'rs are relic keep campers, minstrels and skalds (gotta have speed for the fking downtime).

It's the same server as Uthgard 1 after the BG and Tagendi nerf. Only now with a lot more people. Uthard population never died because of Genesis opening. It died because they closed the BG's. Which was a try to get people to RvR in the frontiers.

Ask yourself a question. Why would I go out with a sub par pug and RvR at this point? You don't? That's right. That's why the casual pug doesn't exist in RvR. No RP bonus for keep taking or whatever will save it.



True , and funny enough these so called elite grps rr7+ now kill soloers and chase em down Emain .. ofc its no fun when its just rps hungry , smallmen is hard to play aswell cause fg s dont search 8 vs 8 fight ..they d chase a lvl 1 player if they ll see it, fuken pathetic .

joshisanonymous wrote:
Andreas wrote:The only problem is that midgard is to strong. They are the counter realm against hib and alb cant handle them especially because they have relict advantage.

To solve thise it would be necessary that alot of mids change there realm or the admins give the other realms improvments.

But these dont happen because:
1. Player wont switch realms because midgard is funnier to play
2. Admins dont want to do custom changes
3. Events are not be used to give hib and alb the advantages which they would need

Possible solutions:
1. Instand realm transfer from midgard to another realm
2. Events especially for alb and hib to give them a chance to close the gap between them and mid (exp and rp)
3. Custom changes (for example det for champions and palas)
4. New bonus system which close the gap between the realms and not makes the best ralm even better (examples: relict bonus reducing over time, stronger keep guards if your realm has less keeps, rp bonus if your realm gains less rp last week, ...).


Now u can hate me.


No hate, but please try to take the relics. The devs didn't hand the relics to Mid and Mid doesn't have some crazy imbalanced abilities that make it a piece of cake to get them. We didn't even have particularly huge numbers when we went and the raids failed several times I believe before we got them. The reason it worked is because Riyu decided to organize raids and to keep doing it even after failed runs.

So take them back. Plan it out. Hibs and Albs can gang up on Mid even. It doesn't make much sense to fight each other if you both want relics and Mid is unlikely to be able to defend against both at once. If for some reason you fail, try it again. The only reason you might've failed is because Mids went out there and defended, which means that at the very least you're generating large scale battles. Maybe you don't think those fights are fun, but I do and I'm sure many many other players do, many that don't post here on the forums.

If there simply aren't enough people in your realm to even put together 2 groups to at least get a push for relics started, then maybe start doing a /who 1 20 and inviting people into your guilds. Help new players out when they start and maybe they'll stick around and maybe the number of active 50s will increase again. Do something other than posting about how someone else has to fix it for you.

I'm not saying this stuff to be a know-it-all who doesn't know-it-all, I'm saying this stuff to try to help because I'd really like to see large numbers of Hibs and Albs out regularly, and not just a couple elite 8-mans.

By the way, it's kinda interesting that barto22 claims that relics are meaningless and then two posts later someone else claims that RvR is too hard when Mids have relics. I try to imagine that forums are not just places where self-defeatists go to vent, but they probably are.

EDIT: I should say that your suggestion for bonuses at least sounds fairly reasonable. It would make sense to have XP/RP bonuses for underpopulated realms and I think that even existed on live since a very long time ago. I'm not sure holding more relics or keeps shouldn't also give you a bonus, though. We don't really wanna have a situation where realms purposefully try to fall behind so that they can get bonuses. I would think just having higher XP/RP rates based on realm population would be pretty fair. An underdog bonus.

I saw mids having 3-4 fg s middle of hte night EU times composed mostly of USA ppl( guilds) how can we take relics if during night time you bring so much ppl and take everything back?:)
Glacius ( previous acount name)
Albion

Glacius - WIzzard
Disrupter - Armsman

User avatar
Budikah
Phoenix Knight
 
Posts: 1328
Joined: Mar 14, 2010 01:00

Postby Budikah » May 03, 2017 23:58

I don't know why it is the way it is, but in EU times I've seen massive Mid zergs without pretty much any Alb zerg opposition. Come NA time, Alb seems to get the edge, but I've also seen Mids conjure up equal/larger zergs even in NA time.

I don't know the solution - it just seems like one way or another people from different timezones all picked in together which has left some realms seemingly completely undefended. Either that or EU time Albs simply have no leadership - which is also a potential.

I continually consider how to take a relic - but it's holding the relic that is the hard part. If EU Albs just lay down and get their faces smashed to dirt at the slightest hint of opposition, then what is the point of a massive undertaking during a different timezone?

If there are any "zerg" leaders in Alb during EU times, please speak up so we can figure out how to get some goddamn relic mobility.

Ruckuz1983
Myrmidon
 
Posts: 62
Joined: Mar 13, 2017 23:54

Postby Ruckuz1983 » May 04, 2017 04:05

Evinac wrote:
Ruckuz1983 wrote:
Skallman wrote:Funny thing atm.

Watching Tharid's stream on Twitch now a bit.
He's standing on emain pad in Hibernia. And its 17CET atm. 3 fg mids ported to emain couple mins ago, bufed and ran out.. like wtf? 3fg? Some of them high rr to.

Thats the amount hib got on weekends at evnings, not a ordinary weekday at 17CET.. AT Drum Ligen atm, 1 afk bard, 1 afk vw, couple casters ;P YAY!



Hibs always complaining maybe that's why people don't enjoy it there...I deleted a 50 bard just saying.


How's the bandwagon?


Considering I was in your guild it's gone well playing with old guild members...

Then again your idea of fun was running a 2nd group at clip to assjam...

Bandwagon hardly...

My experience in hib.. unless you contributed to focus pulling no groups. If you didn't have the right group to min max something pve they wouldn't let you in... nobody offered to help with my bards template items.. still got scd. BF didn't help with anything other than the 400 per piece sc...

When I rolled mid...

Groups from day one...we had 8 people grouped till lvl 10...playing shaman made things ok until 40 but not nearly as slow as hib was...rolled a RM RC spec... can't really say running mid caster group is the bandwagon...

Bottom line is people in mid help each other. Only downside is the one hour of farming a week to pay for rvr charges but that's really minor... so same amount of time two 50s because people look to group they welcome people and consistently make a full group even if it's not the best ...but it works out and in the end that's alot better than my experience in hib.

However your random shot at me is exactly what is wrong with hib...I'm having fun and youD rather make snide comments than see someone enjoy there time in the game.

Today alone I gave mats farmed to a leveling alchemist and a random shaman in a group near me buffed me while farming so I gave him one of two of the band of ices that dropped while farming...
Infection 50 Shaman
Alliant 50 Runemaster

t-bone
Myrmidon
 
Posts: 154
Joined: Jun 14, 2011 16:12

Postby t-bone » May 04, 2017 12:43

Maybe HIB should stop putting 6-7FG between AMG and Silo in Emain?? so you get more than 24 rps a kill.
You are destroying rvr

Musaks
Warder
 
Posts: 43
Joined: Apr 19, 2017 13:19

Postby Musaks » May 04, 2017 13:02

stop whining about a zerg, its part of the game

field a zerg too or go into one of the other zones and take their keeps

PreviousNext

Return to Realm versus Realm

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 78 guests

Monday, 03. March 2025

Artwork and screen shots Copyright © 2001-2004 Mythic Entertainment, Inc. All rights reserved. Used with permission of Mythic Entertainment. Mythic Entertainment, the Mythic Entertainment logo, "Dark Age of Camelot," "Shrouded Isles," "Foundations," "New Frontiers," "Trials of Atlantis," "Catacombs," "Darkness Rising," the Dark Age of Camelot and subsequent logos, and the stylized Celtic knot are trademarks of Mythic Entertainment, Inc.

Valid XHTML & CSS | Original Design by: LernVid.com | Modified by Uthgard Staff